Closing the Gap: An Imperative for Paid Family Leave

The United States is the only high-income country in the world that does not have paid parental leave. Paid family leave (PFL) in the United States is a crucial workplace benefit that allows employees to take time off work with pay to care for family members or personal health conditions. Despite its importance, the U.S. lacks a comprehensive federal PFL policy, resulting in a patchwork of state-driven initiatives and private sector efforts.

As of 2023, only 27% of private sector workers and 28% of state and local government workers in the U.S. had access to paid family leave benefits. This is significantly lower than other high-income countries, where paid leave is often guaranteed by law. The absence of a federal mandate has led to substantial disparities in access to paid leave, with only 13 states and the District of Columbia having implemented some form of guaranteed paid family and medical leave legislation.

Research indicates that paid family leave is associated with numerous benefits, including decreased infant mortality rates, improved physical and mental health for new parents, and greater financial security for caregivers. For instance, new mothers who take paid leave are 54% more likely to report wage increases and are more likely to stay in the workforce compared to those who do not or cannot take leave​.

Furthermore, the U.S. stands out as the only high-income country that does not guarantee paid leave for parental, caregiving, or medical purposes at the federal level. This lack of support contributes to the relatively low labor force participation rate among U.S. women, which has been declining since the 1990s​​. The economic impact is significant, with the U.S. economy losing an estimated $500 billion per year due to the lack of comprehensive paid leave policies​.

To better navigate our discussion, it’s important to define key terms associated with paid family leave and understand the existing federal legislation.

Definitions & Federal Law

Paid family leave encompasses several key terms:

• Paid Family Leave (PFL): Time off from work with pay to care for family members or personal health conditions. This can include parental leave, personal medical leave, and leave related to caring for a family member with an illness or injury.
• Maternity Leave: Leave specifically for a mother related to childbirth, or adoption or foster placement of a newborn, and subsequent care.
• Paternity Leave: Leave specifically for fathers after the birth, adoption, or foster placement of a child.
• Parental Leave: A gender-neutral term to describe all types of leave taken to care for a newborn child.
• Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA): Federal law providing up to 12 weeks of unpaid, job-protected leave per year for qualifying family and medical reasons.
• Short-Term Disability: A policy or insurance that partially replaces income for a limited time due to either a disability that temporarily prevents work or recovery from childbirth.

Let’s distinguish between the broader category of family leave and the specific subset of parental leave to appreciate their unique impacts.

The Distinction Between Family and Parental Leave

The terms “family leave” and “parental leave” are often used interchangeably, but they have distinct meanings:

• Family Leave: Family leave encompasses any leave taken to care for family members of any age with serious health conditions. This includes caring for a spouse, domestic partner, parent, grandparent, or sibling in addition to a child. Family leave policies recognize the diverse caregiving responsibilities employees may have and provide the necessary support to balance work and family life.
• Parental Leave: Parental leave specifically refers to the time off granted to parents for the birth, adoption, or foster care placement of a child. Parental leave focuses on the bonding period between the parent and the new child, promoting family well-being and healthy child development. It is a subset of family leave that addresses the unique needs of new parents during the early stages of parenthood.

Moving on, we have some examples of how individual states and cities, like New York and Washington, D.C., are pioneering innovations in paid family leave policies.

State Examples and Innovations in Paid Family Leave

New York and Washington D.C. are two examples of governments that have set precedents with their comprehensive PFL policies:

• Washington, D.C. Paid Family Leave: Offers up to eight weeks of parental leave, six weeks for family care, and two weeks for personal medical care. Benefits are available to all private-sector employees, and self-employed individuals have an option to opt-in​.

• New York State Paid Family Leave: Provides up to 12 weeks of leave at 67% of the employee’s average weekly wage, covering a wide range of caregiving needs including bonding with a new child, caring for a family member with a serious health condition, and addressing family needs arising from a military deployment​.

Paid family leave is a prime example of the idiom “a rising tide lifts all boats” by benefiting its recipients directly as well as playing a consequential role in closing the gender wage gap. As women are disproportionately impacted by both childbirth and broader caregiving responsibilities within the family, we will analyze how PFL supports women’s workforce participation and long-term financial security.

Addressing the Gender Gap

Paid family leave is pivotal in closing the gender wage gap through a variety of means:

Impact on Women’s Workforce Participation:

• Support for Continuous Employment: Women are more likely to remain in the workforce when they have access to paid leave. Research has shown that women are 20% less likely to leave the workforce when they have access to paid leave. This continuous employment is crucial for career advancement and long-term earning potential.
• Reduction in Income Disruption: Without paid leave, women are often forced take unpaid leave or exit the workforce temporarily, leading to significant income loss. Paid leave helps mitigate these disruptions, providing a steady income and supporting long-term financial stability.

Long-Term Financial Security:

• Retirement Savings and Benefits: Continuous employment enabled by PFL contributes to better retirement savings and benefits. Women typically receive 20% less in Social Security benefits than men due to time taken off for caregiving. PFL helps reduce this gap by ensuring women remain in the workforce and continue contributing to their retirement plans.
• Reduced Poverty Risk: Family leave benefits reduces the risk of poverty for mothers and provides them with a safety net, which is especially crucial for low-income workers. After California instituted a paid family leave program, the risk of poverty among mothers of infants decreased by 10.2% percent and their household incomes increased by 4.1% percent on average. Additionally, it reduced food insecurity among households following childbirth.

Encouraging Shared Caregiving Responsibilities:

• Equitable Distribution of Caregiving: PFL policies that include paternity leave encourage fathers to take time off and share in caregiving responsibilities. This not only supports mothers in returning to work but also promotes a more balanced division of labor at home​.
• Changing Workplace Norms: The availability of paid leave for both parents helps normalize the idea that caregiving is a shared responsibility. This cultural shift is essential for reducing gender discrimination in the workplace and promoting gender equality.

Policy Recommendations for Gender Equality:

• Inclusive and Comprehensive Leave Policies: To truly advance gender equality, PFL policies must cover all working people, be gender-inclusive, and reflect the diverse forms families take today. This includes recognizing and supporting chosen families and LGBTQ+ families​.
• Sustainable Funding Models: Effective PFL programs should be sustainably funded and cost-effective for workers, employers, and the government. This ensures that the benefits are meaningful and do not force workers into trade-offs between access to leave and financial security​.

Despite progress over the years, there are notable gaps in PFL coverage under current federal and state laws. Families lose an estimated $20.6 billion in wages each year due to inadequate or no paid leave. Implementing PFL can significantly reduce this economic burden​. We’ll explore these shortcomings and the need for more inclusive policies.

Current Gaps in Federal and State Laws

Without a federally mandated, comprehensive PFL policy in the US, the current hodgepodge of federal and state policies remain fragmented and often insufficient.

• Inadequate Coverage: The eligibility criteria for PFL excludes large segments of the workforce. For example, 73% of private sector workers do not currently have access to PFL. This lack of coverage disproportionately impacts low-wage workers, part-time employees, and employees of small businesses who do not qualify for paid leave under current policies that require a minimum number of working hours or company size thresholds. Consequently, the very workers who may benefit most from paid leave are often those left without any coverage.
• Limited Duration and Wage Replacement: Current PFL policies typically offer only a fraction of earned wages and are restricted to a limited number of weeks. For instance, while some states may provide up to 12 weeks of paid leave, the wage replacement rate rarely exceeds two-thirds of the employee’s regular salary, and, in some cases, it is much lower. This limited financial support can be insufficient to cover basic living costs for families during leave periods, particularly in areas with a high cost of living, forcing workers to shorten their leave.
• Lack of Inclusivity: Many existing PFL policies fail to address the needs of diverse family structures. Traditional definitions of “family” used in these policies often exclude non-biological, non-marital, and LGBTQ+ relationships, which can prevent individuals from using leave to care for an ill or disabled partner or relative who is not recognized by state or federal definitions. This further restricts the support that PFL policies can otherwise offer to workers.

These gaps underscore the need for a comprehensive review and reform of PFL policies to make them more inclusive, equitable, and supportive for all workers, regardless of their employment type, wage level, or family structure.

Within these gaps, businesses can play a pivotal role in shaping PFL policies. Next, we will discuss how corporate leadership can advance paid family leave and promote workplace equality.

Opportunities for Business Leadership

Businesses have a powerful role in advancing PFL policies and can set industry standards by implementing comprehensive and inclusive programs. Here’s how:

1. Exceed State Requirements: Offer longer leave durations and higher wage replacements than mandated. Ensure policies are inclusive of diverse family structures, including chosen families and LGBTQ+ families.
2. Promote Gender Equality: Actively promote and encourage paternity leave to normalize shared caregiving responsibilities. This helps reduce the burden on women and supports gender equality. Providing equal leave for all parents breaks down caregiving stereotypes.
3. Foster a Supportive Work Environment: Support employees transitioning back to work with return-to-work programs, including flexible arrangements and phased returns. Integrate PFL with other benefits like health insurance and childcare support.
4. Advocate for Policy Changes: Publicly advocate for comprehensive federal PFL policies by supporting legislation like the FAMILY Act, and partner with industry groups and advocacy organizations to promote broader PFL adoption.
5. Measure and Communicate the Impact: Collect data on PFL’s impact on retention, productivity, and well-being to demonstrate its business benefits. Publicize positive outcomes to inspire other businesses and promote cultural change. Robust and competitive PFL policies reduce turnover costs, enhance employee loyalty and morale, and attract top talent by offering better work-life balance.
6. Create a Culture of Care: Ensure visible commitment from company leaders to drive cultural change, and educate employees about their PFL rights and access to benefits​.

By leading on PFL, businesses can create a supportive work environment, drive positive economic outcomes, and influence broader policy changes, ultimately benefiting employees and the organization alike.

As the U.S. continues to grapple with the evolving demands of work and family life, developing a comprehensive, inclusive, and accessible federal paid family leave policy becomes ever more critical. Learning from state successes and addressing current policy gaps will be key in shaping a future where all workers can thrive without having to sacrifice their family responsibilities or career aspirations.

Let us share experiences.  Leave a comment below, send me an email, or find me on Twitter.